National Geographic against Romania and Bulgaria

Tu la ce ONG lucrezi? Chiar atat de prost esti incat nu ti-ai gasit si tu o meserie mai normala, decat meseria de propagandist de doi lei pe net? Tiganii nu sunt romi, jigodie, ci sunt indieni din Punjabi, veniti in Europa acum foarte multe sute de ani. Termenul de romi, a fost inventat pt tigani de niste jeguri rasiste asa *** esti si tu, care vor sa creeze confuzie intre romani si tigani, si sa ii trimita pe toti tiganii din Europa de Vest in Romania.

Draga barro27, pe tine te omoara in schimb prostia. Pe Banica junior l-am trecut la romani, pt ca e cel putin jumate roman. Taica-su, o fi fost tigan dupa *** zici, dar maica-sa e romanca. Oricum, asa *** in America devii american in 5 ani, cred ca si in Romania ai dreptul sa devii roman dupa ce ai stat aici sute de ani, vorbesti limba romana, ai si sange romanesc si te mai si consideri roman pe deasupra. Daca el se considera roman si este perfect integrat in societate, il consider si eu.

4. I don’t know my haplogroup, since I am a woman and I don’t have the Y chromosome. But I know exactly how the people from my familly look like, and they look typicaly from the Balkan are. For you to say that I can not about haplogroups only because I am a girl, or only because I don’t know which is mine, is just stupid, because that means all the scientists in the world are not allowed to talk about other haplogroups, because they belong to just one haplogroup.

Ok, so this will be my final comment.

1. Croatians are not Romanians.

2. Romanians do not belong just to haplogroup I

3. You are arguing the point that all Romanians are from this halpogroup which is wrong.

4. You don’t know your own haplogroup, so you could be arguing the point without even belonging to this haplogroup.

It’s that simple.

rogerstan- what exactly do you want to prove?What is your point?
My point is that all the people who have the I haplogorup belong to the ancient Balkanic race names THRACIANS, so, they are ROMANIANS who lost their true identity. The Bosnians are not SLAVS, because they have the I haplgroup, while the Slavs have the R1a.
In Bosnia 70% of the people belong to the I haplogroup,which means they are THRACIANS also.

What about typing “AROMANIANS in BOSNIaA” or to type “frisian ROMANIA” and you will gone find alot about the subject. Even on wikipedia you will find that Bosnia was inhabited before the Slavs came in the area, and all those people inhabiting,had Thracian roots, which means were Romanians. I am a girl, not a man, so I do not have a Y chromosome.

Thirdly- before the Slavs came , the majority of the people inhabiting the Balkan area were speaking ROMANIAN language. After the Slavs came, people were separated, and their languages started to become dialects of the Romanian language, just like Istro-Romana, Megleno-Romana etc. In time, this people were forced to speak Bulgarian, Serbian and they were forced to consider themselv other races than they really were. Modern Bosnian are Romanians by blood, Slavs as language, Muslim as religion.

First of all, rogerstan- the oldest places inhabitted by a civilized group of people, is not Bosnia, but it is the Valley of the Danube, a place which is today in Romania or in those areas inhabited by Romanians in Serbia/Bulgaria= Timok Valley. People formed in this area, and from here spread North and South, in Bosnia, Bulgaria, Greece, Ukraina etc.

This doesn’t prove a thing. There are places in Austria with Croatian names that does not mean that the Austrians are assimilated Croats! The West Balkans was a refuge during the last glacial maximum for peoples all over Europe at the time. They dispersed after the the LGM to other regions of Europe including Romania not the other way around. Anyway, I would not make a blanket claim to this Haplogroup personally unless you have been tested. I know that I am I1b.

Bosnian Croats have the highest Haplogroup I in the world at 70% even higher than the Scandinavians. To say that Croats are assimilated Romanians is complete madness. This haplogroup originated in modern day Bosnia 20,000 years ago and is still found in the original population there so there were no migrations from Romania. Go to Wikkipeadia and read what is says about this.

Dear, paranoia is only in your head. The haplogroup I is typically for the ancient THRACIAN population. Unfortunatelly, some of these people have been culturally assimilated, many of them during communist time, and today they think they are Slavs, while they actually are just Romanians who lost their identity. You forgat to mention that in Bosnia there are still mountans having the name ROMANIA, and that in the entire Balcan there are still many Romanians and Aromanians.

mie mi-ar placea sa se dea pedeapsa cu mortea pt traficanti de droguri, pt vanzatorii de droguri si pt cei care incurajeaza consumul de droguri. Si mi-ar placea sa te vad pedepsit pt ca incurajezi consumul de droguri. Asta esti- o jigodie platita sa discrediteze valorile romanilor si sa ii indemne pe romani pe o cale gresita. *** zicea Talmudul? Ca daca vezi un crestin pe marginea prapastiei sa ii faci vant? Exact mentalitatea asta criminala o ai si sper sa fii rasplatit pt ea.